Politics & Governance / Pakistan

FCC amends stay order, letting Peshawar High Court resume Article 199 cases

The Federal Constitutional Court narrowed the 5 November stay order on 16 November, letting the Peshawar High Court resume Article 199 petitions except 3-MPO and emergency cases.

Reporting snapshot · 16 November 2026 (Asia/Karachi). The court has not published the amended order, so its precise wording and the list of cases it still catches are not yet on the record; what is settled is that the Peshawar High Court's writ docket reopens for most categories, and that people detained under 3-MPO have no review board to go to until around mid-February 2027.

A wide, tree-lined avenue in Islamabad with a grass verge and street lights, a blue sign pointing to the Supreme Court of Pakistan, and low hills behind.
ARCHIVAL CONTEXT Shahra-e-Dastoor (Constitution Avenue) in Islamabad, photographed on 6 May 2018, with a sign pointing to the Supreme Court of Pakistan. The Federal Shariat Court building, which houses the Federal Constitutional Court, also stands on this avenue but is not the structure in view, and the photograph does not show the court, the bench or the November 2026 hearing. Photo: Msirfankhalid via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0. Downloaded at 960 × 539 pixels; no cropping, retouching or resizing.

On Monday, 16 November, the Federal Constitutional Court narrowed the stay order it had imposed on the Peshawar High Court eleven days earlier, telling the high court that it may resume hearing writ petitions in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa apart from the categories that order was about. A two-member bench — Chief Justice Aminuddin Khan and Justice Aamer Farooq — approved a petition filed by the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf and said the 5 November stay had been directed at arrests under Section 3 of the Maintenance of Public Order Ordinance and at the province’s emergency and governor’s rule, Geo News reported.

Dunya News reported that the court found its stay order concerned governor’s rule and the MPO, and added that the Peshawar High Court could continue hearing other cases under Article 199 of the Constitution. Daily Times reported that the bench amended the stay order after hearing argument from PTI counsel Barrister Gohar. The constitutional case itself was adjourned indefinitely.

The order that closed the docket

On 5 November the constitutional court barred the Peshawar High Court from hearing cases arising from arrests under the MPO Ordinance until further orders, acting on the provincial government’s challenge to high court orders that had set aside the preventive detentions of PTI workers and stopped further arrests, The Express Tribune reported. Geo News described those orders as restraining arrests under 3-MPO and directing the release of 28 PTI workers detained in districts of the province. Dunya News called the 5 November order an interim restraint until further notice. KhabarWire covered the order when it was made.

The high court then carried it out more widely than the words required. On 7 November its administrative committee directed that no writ petition filed on or after 12 October would be listed for hearing, that new petitions would not be received at the filing counter, and that they would be returned with instructions to approach the appropriate forum — a closure that reached ordinary petitions with nothing to do with preventive detention, as KhabarWire reported.

Gohar told the bench on Monday that the 5 November order had affected the high court’s proceedings and had brought lawyers’ professional practice to a halt, Geo News said. The Peshawar Bar Council was also granted permission to join the proceedings as a party, Geo News and Daily Times both reported.

Why Article 245 was not read literally

The province’s case rested on Article 245 of the Constitution, the provision the federal government invoked when the army was called in to aid the civil administration in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa. The provincial advocate general argued that a high court could not interfere in areas where military operations were under way, and could not exercise its writ jurisdiction there, The Express Tribune reported. That argument carried the day on 5 November: the constitutional court’s written judgment held that proceedings on Article 199 petitions filed on or after 12 October stood suspended by virtue of Article 245(4), as KhabarWire reported at the time.

On Monday the bench declined to carry it through. Justice Aamer Farooq observed that a straightforward reading of Article 245 suggested cases under Article 199 could not be heard at all, but that a literal interpretation of the provision would bring the entire judicial system to a standstill, Geo News and Daily Times both reported. The court had put the same point on 5 November, when the judge asked whether the high court would not hear the cases brought before it every day, The Express Tribune reported.

The review board that does not exist

Gohar asked the bench for relief for the people arrested under Section 3 of the MPO, pointing out that the review board the ordinance requires had still not been constituted in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa. The provincial advocate general told the court that the board would be formed after three months.

That is the gap that remains open. The release of the detained workers, ordered by the high court and then suspended by the constitutional court, now depends on a review panel that does not exist and that, on the account given to the bench, will take until around mid-February 2027. Chief Justice Aminuddin Khan told Gohar that the miscellaneous petitions had been filed at the Peshawar Registry and would be examined once they reached the bench, so the request for the detainees’ relief will be considered by the constitutional court rather than by the high court that granted it.

What reopens, and what does not

For the first time since 7 November, the Peshawar High Court can take up writ petitions that have no connection to preventive detention or to the emergency. Article 199 is the provision through which a high court hears complaints against administrative action, including unlawful detention, and issues directions to public authorities; during the suspension the court was returning petitions unfiled. No figure for the backlog has been published.

Two categories stay out. Petitions concerning arrests under 3-MPO remain covered by the stay order, and the bench confirmed that the high court will not hear cases concerning the imposition of governor’s rule or a state of emergency in the province. That second exclusion is the significant change for the Khyber Pakhtunkhwa file: the petitions challenging the emergency proclaimed in the province on 11 October and the transfer of power to Governor Faisal Karim Kundi cannot be heard by the high court. The separate challenge to those measures, lodged in the constitutional court on 20 October, remains the route for them, as KhabarWire reported when it was filed.

Where the petitions about the whereabouts of the province’s missing legislators fall is not settled. Sohail Afridi’s brother moved the high court on 13 October seeking his whereabouts and an inquiry into his disappearance; the petition was filed while the high court was also seeking replies from the governor and the speaker against the governor’s rule, The Express Tribune reported. Whether a petition about a person detained under emergency rule counts as a case “concerning” governor’s rule, or as an ordinary Article 199 complaint, is precisely the question the bench’s unpublished order will settle.

The clarification also lands alongside two other decisions that have reshaped how the two courts relate. In October the constitutional court held that its rulings on questions of law bind all courts, and in November it said that judgments of the Supreme Court carry only persuasive value for it, as KhabarWire reported. KhabarWire follows the file in its Khyber Pakhtunkhwa emergency hub.